This week's Torah portion, Toldot, sets a family rivalry center-stage. As twins, Jacob and Esau wrestle in their mother Rebecca's womb. After they're born, the Torah describes them -- both in terms of physical appearance and interests -- as polar opposites. On one occasion, Jacob takes advantage of Esau's hunger, purchasing his birthright (double portion of inheritance) for the price of a bowl of stew. The climax of the rivalry comes when Jacob disguises himself as his brother -- complete with hairy fore-arms -- to trick their father Isaac into giving him the blessing intended for the firstborn son alone.
Reading this Torah portion always feels emotionally painful to me, and it's tempting to muse about where the fault lies for the tragedy of this extreme family situation. Does Esau's coarseness and love of hunting hint at underlying malice and wickedness (as many rabbinic sources claim), in which case Jacob's trickery can be understood as justified? Or should we point a finger more self-critically at our own ancestor Jacob, whose trickery needs to be called out? Yet another very reasonable possibility would be to blame the parents: after all, Isaac and Rebecca both show extreme favoritism, with Isaac carrying the generational trauma of having grown up with a father who also pitted two siblings against one another, and Rebecca pulling puppet strings and showing willingness to deceive even her own spouse. If we're looking for who to blame and assume we need to pick just one villain, there are many candidates we should consider.
If, however, we can back up and widen our view, we can see that the problem may lie not in the actions of any one character, but in the system itself and its either/or thinking. Why should it be the case that only one child can receive a parental blessing? Why couldn't there have been two such blessings? Why did Isaac and Rebecca need to choose sides, each expressing love for only one of the twins (as Gen. 25:28 literally records)? Apparently the biblical author couldn't envision a world in which both children could be equally loved, equally resourced, and equally blessed, but hopefully today we can envision such a world.
And yet, even today, the mentality of scarcity of resources and either/or thinking crops up everywhere. We've seen it throughout the election season we've just come through... for example, through political ads that claim, either explicitly or implicitly, that we can care about either citizens or newcomers to America but not both. Ballot initiatives targeting trans youth were fueled by politicians who fomented anxiety about the need to protect (the rest of) our children.
Again, there is faulty logic at play here. If only we can take in a zoomed-out picture, we should be able to see that, as in Parashat Toldot, our political landscape should not be a zero-sum game. In the wake of the Election Day tsunami, I'm grateful to see photos of such diverse classes of new representatives, senators and governors. To me, this feels like such a breath of fresh air -- a strong repudiation by "we the people" of a politic that conspires to sow fear and pit minority groups against each other.
As we continue reading Genesis over the coming weeks, we get to watch a system change slowly. The most dramatic rivalries -- the ones that exacerbate competition and cast one sibling against another, and I'm thinking here of those between Isaac and Ishmael, Jacob and Esau, Joseph and his brothers -- eventually pass and make way for something new. By the time we reach Genesis 48, we'll meet another patriarch whose "eyes are dim with age." There, however, it's not Isaac (as in this week's Torah portion), but rather Jacob himself; he has gone from being the child desperately seeking his father's innermost blessing to playing the role of the vision-impaired grandfather, ready to transmit blessing to a new generation. As he does so, his grandchildren, Joseph's sons Ephraim and Menashe, will stand before him. Hands crossed, and purposefully rejecting the idea that the oldest must be his right-hand pick, he blesses both of his grandchildren at the same time.
I heard an echo of this older and wiser Jacob as I listened to U.S. Senator-elect James Talarico's election night victory speech from Texas last week. He said (among many other beautiful words):
"I think it's safe to say that we are tired of being pitted against each other. We are tired of being told to hate each other. It has been 10 years of this kind of politics, politics as blood sport, politics as trolling and owning, politics as professional wrestling...
Love, love can heal what's broken in America. We can't defeat the politics of division with more division. We can't win that game. We have to change the game."
In this week's parasha, Rebecca and Isaac, Esau and Jacob are all trapped within a system of competition, one that pits them against each other and insists that one person's gains must come at the hands of someone else's loss. As we read their story and lament the fear and pain that all of these characters must have experienced, let us try to step back and gain perspective, on both their lives and our own, until we can see that another reality is possible. Indeed, we have to change the game... and as with Jacob, the power to do so lies in our own hands.
Shabbat Shalom,
Rabbi Rachel Nussbaum